Increase Repeat Purchase Rate: Turning One-Time Buyers into Brand Loyalists

Unlock the secret to turning one-time buyers into loyal customers: boost repeat purchase rates and drive sustainable eCommerce growth with strategic retention tactics.

Alex JostAlex Jost
Founder of RetentionX · Nov 13, 2025 · 10-minute read

Your best customers are the ones you already have! After a customer has placed an order, it is your job to inspire them to place another order. Therefore, it is important to time your retargeting campaigns to increase the chances of catching your customer's attention. RetentionX can help you do this:

Key takeaways
1
Repeat purchase rate by order number is the share of customers who place order n+1 after order n. It shows where you lose customers, which one blended Shopify rate hides.
2
The second order is the steepest drop: across 3 Shopify brands in RetentionX, only 21–34% of new customers ever came back.
3
Once customers place order two, 44–58% place a third, and every later step keeps more of them.
4
Nudge one-time buyers when they pass the median days between order 1 and 2, not on a fixed calendar.
5
Build dynamic segments of overdue customers by order number and send each one a different message.
In this post
01Critical Step to Loyalty →
02RetentionX data: repeat rate by order number →
03When to reactivate customers →
04Repeat customer action chart →
05How to increase repeat purchase rate in Shopify →
06FAQ →
Part 1 · The walkthrough

Critical Step to Loyalty

Typically, the biggest challenge is converting one-time buyers into repeat customers. Building customer loyalty is crucial in this process as it not only converts one-time buyers into repeat customers but also fosters brand advocacy and a steady revenue stream. Benchmarks show that the likelihood of a repeat purchase increases with each subsequent purchase - in fact, a second purchase results in an average of three additional orders over the lifetime of the customer. So let’s understand at what order number your customers become loyal and make it a habit to buy from your brand again and again, recognizing that repeat purchases are a key factor in fostering this loyalty. Your goal should be to get your customers to that level of loyalty.

Check your customer data with the Repeat Purchase Rate Analysis. For each order, this analysis shows the percentage of customers who placed a repeat order. This report answers important questions like How many of your first-time buyers returned for a second purchase? How many of them made a third purchase?

Identify the order number at which the repeat purchase rate stabilizes at a high level. Now it is up to you to incentivize your customers to reach at least this order number.

This analysis is very different from the aggregated repeat purchase rate you get in Shopify. The average means nothing if, for example, you lose 80% of your customers between the first and second order.

Repeat Purchase Rate in Shopify

Shopify also has a repurchase rate analysis, but you can't really use it. This is because of the following.

  • Shopify calculates the repurchase rate as the ratio of existing customers to total customers, but not how many of your customers come back at all.

  • Shopify also doesn't differentiate where you're losing customers and doesn't offer a return rate by number of orders. There are huge differences. Typically, the second order is very critical.

  • As a result, Shopify often gives a highly embellished picture of the actual state. We have seen many brands that claim to have a 60% repurchase rate, but have not been able to get 80% of their customers to place a second order.

– therefore Shopify does not provide a reliable Repeat Purchase Rate metric out of the box

Repeat Purchase Rate Benchmarks

With the latest release of RetentionX, your Shopify data is constantly monitored and benchmarked against your industry. Understanding customer lifetime value is crucial in this context, as it helps in measuring the direct impact on your revenue when you reach the industry standard, by focusing on customer retention, repeat purchase rate, and average order value. This approach emphasizes the importance of maximizing repeat customer rates to unlock customer lifetime value and sustain revenue growth in ecommerce.

When to reactivate customers

Now that we know which order is critical to building loyalty, when is it overdue? Time Between Purchases analysis helps you understand the regular buying patterns of your customers. The median number of days between purchases indicates when a customer’s next order is overdue. Only after this time has elapsed should customers receive additional inspiration or incentives.

It is important to analyze the purchase frequency separately for each order number as the time between purchases usually decreases with every subsequent purchase. Utilizing insights from the Time Between Purchases analysis can effectively encourage repeat purchases by offering targeted incentives that cater to the individual's purchasing behavior.

For example, if the median days between the 1st and 2nd orders is 78 days, all customers who placed their first and only order more than 78 days ago are past due.

Segment overdue customers

To put these insights into action, we need to identify the customers we want to work with based on customer segments. For this, segment all overdue customers who haven’t yet placed the number of orders required to achieve loyalty. E.g., all overdue customers who have shopped either once, twice, or three times. Taking one-time buyers as an example, the segment conditions are as follows:

Analyzing customer feedback is crucial in refining the segmentation of overdue customers, as it allows us to understand their needs and preferences better, ultimately improving customer satisfaction and the rate of returning customers.

But that is not all. RetentionX automates this process by determining whether each customer’s next order is overdue based on their progress through the customer journey. This means that loyal existing customers become past due faster than new customers. This dynamic information can easily be used as a segmentation criteria:

Create dynamic audiences

Understanding the importance of customer retention and how exceptional customer service can turn new customers into loyal customers is crucial for ecommerce success. To engage with these customers, start by connecting your favorite email marketing platform, such as Klaviyo, to RetentionX. Considering the rising costs of customer acquisition, it's more financially beneficial to focus on your existing customer base to improve the repeat customer rate. Be sure to select segments to add to your contact profiles, including those of returning customers, emphasizing their significance in sustaining a healthy repeat purchase rate. This will put your insights where your marketing team needs them. Unlike traditional subscriber lists, segments are dynamic, meaning they grow when customers meet the segment conditions and shrink when they no longer meet the conditions. Use your customer segment information to create audiences that target your delinquent customers and reach them at the right time.

To engage with these customers, start by connecting your favorite email marketing platform, such as Klaviyo, to RetentionX. Be sure to select segments to add to your contact profiles. This will put your insights where your marketing team needs them. Unlike traditional subscriber lists, segments are dynamic, meaning they grow when customers meet the segment conditions and shrink when they no longer meet the conditions. Use your customer segment information to create audiences that target your delinquent customers and reach them at the right time.

With RetentionX, the same customer segment can be used simultaneously across all your channels.

Part 2 · The guide

What is repeat purchase rate by order number?

This section gives you the definition and the three numbers you need before you change any flow.

Definition
Repeat purchase rate by order number is the share of customers who place their next order after a given order: second after first, third after second, and so on.
It answers where customers drop off. The blended rate in Shopify (returning customers ÷ all customers) can look healthy while most first-time buyers never come back.

It is a different number from the overall repeat purchase rate, which tells you how many customers ever came back. The per-order view tells you which step to fix.

The formulas
Repeat rate, order n → n+1
customers with ≥ n+1 orders ÷ customers with ≥ n orders × 100
Median days between orders
median(days from order n to order n+1) for customers who placed both
Overdue date for a customer
date of last order + median gap for their order number
Worked example
10,000 first-time buyers, 2,800 place a second order, 1,500 a third. Order 1 → 2 is 28%, order 2 → 3 is 1,500 ÷ 2,800 = 54%. The first step loses 72% of customers, so that is where the next email budget goes.

RetentionX data: repeat rate by order number

We pulled the same view for three Shopify brands in RetentionX. It shows how steep the first step is compared with every step after it.

RetentionX data · 3 Shopify brands
The second order is the hardest one.
Share of customers who place the next order, by order number.
Brand1st → 2nd2nd → 3rd3rd → 4th4th → 5th
Apparel34%58%69%74%
Beauty26%46%57%63%
Food21%44%55%63%
Share of customers who placed order n+1 among those who placed order n. 2024 first-order cohorts (9,133 / 20,109 / 20,174 new customers), orders through November 2026. Exchanges not counted as repeat orders.
Two in three new customers never order again. The ones who do are already halfway to a habit.

The pattern holds across apparel, beauty and food: the second order is the gate. This matches what customer half-life and cohort analysis show from the other side. Before you read your own numbers, check that exchanges are not inflating your second orders.

Repeat customer action chart: when to nudge each order number

This chart turns the per-order rates and median gaps into one plan: who to reach, on which day, with what.

Worked example · action chart
Each order number gets its own nudge.
When to reach overdue customers and what to send.
StageNudge on dayWho is in itWhat to send
Order 1 → 278One-time buyers past the median gapThe next product most second orders contain, no discount first
Order 2 → 355Two-time buyers past the gapRefill or the next step in the range
Order 3 → 440Three-time buyers past the gapEarly access or a loyalty perk
Order 4+—Your habit buyersNo extra push. Protect the margin
Worked example. Day 78 is the median gap from the example above; the later gaps are illustrative and follow the pattern that time between purchases shrinks with every order. Use your own medians.
The nudge moves earlier with each order, and the incentive gets smaller, not bigger.
The takeaway
One cadence for everyone sends too early to new customers and too late to loyal ones. Set the date per order number, as in stop using one cadence for everyone, and for consumables use the replenishment time of the product.
Part 3 · Do it yourself

How to increase repeat purchase rate in Shopify: step by step

You can run a first version of this with a Shopify export and your email tool. These are the steps.

In Shopify · 7 steps
1
Export customers with order counts
Shopify Admin → Customers, filter by number of orders (1, 2, 3).
2
Find your critical order number
Compute the repeat rate for each step. The first step where it levels off is your loyalty line.
3
Measure the median gap
For each step, take the median days between order n and n+1.
4
Build one segment per order number
Customers with n orders whose last order is older than the median gap.
5
Sync segments to Klaviyo
One flow per segment, triggered when a customer enters it.
6
Send product first, discount last
Lead with the next product; hold incentives for customers 1.5× past the gap.
7
Re-check every quarter
Recompute the rates and gaps per cohort; move the nudge dates if they shift.

Common repeat purchase mistakes

MistakeDo this instead
Reading Shopify’s blended repurchase rateTrack the rate per order number, starting with 1st → 2nd
Sending every buyer the same day-30 emailTime each nudge to the median gap for that order number
Discounting the first reminderLead with the next product; save incentives for late customers
Counting exchanges as second ordersExclude exchanges before you measure repeat rate
Using static listsUse dynamic segments that update as customers order

FAQ

How do you get repeat customers in ecommerce?
Find the order number where customers stick, then get more people to it. Measure repeat rate per order number, nudge one-time buyers when they pass the median gap between order one and two, and send product-led messages before discounts. Most brands lose the majority of customers between the first and second order, so start there.
What is a good repeat purchase rate?
It depends on category and time window. In RetentionX data from 3 Shopify brands, 21–34% of 2024 first-time buyers placed a second order by November 2026, and 44–58% of those placed a third. Compare yourself with your own past cohorts first, then with your category.
How do you increase repeat purchase rate?
Work on one step at a time. Raise the first-to-second order rate with timed reminders and the right next product, then the second-to-third with refills or range steps. A blended rate goes up when the weakest step improves, so fix the step with the biggest drop.
When should you send a repeat purchase email?
When a customer passes the median days between their current and next order. If your median gap from order one to two is 78 days, one-time buyers become overdue on day 79. Later orders usually come faster, so each order number needs its own timing.
Why is Shopify’s repeat customer rate misleading?
Shopify shows returning customers as a share of all customers in a period. It does not show how many first-time buyers ever came back or where you lose them. A brand can report a 60% returning rate while 80% of new customers never place a second order.