Whale Hunting: a customer acquisition strategy built on your top 20%

Unlock the secret to profitable eCommerce growth: Learn how top brands strategically target high-value customers that drive 70% of revenue and transform acquisition strategies.

Alex JostAlex Jost
Founder of RetentionX · Dec 11, 2025 · 6-minute read

I say this often, so at this point I hope everyone knows that a small slice of customers typically drives most of the profit for an e-commerce business.

You've probably seen the stat too, something like 20% of buyers generating 70% of revenue. Here's what I find really interesting though...

If you watch how most brands actually spend their customer acquisition dollars, you'd draw the conclusion that they don't know this. They optimize for volume. They celebrate new orders. They chase blended CAC targets as if all customers are created equal.

But, of course. They're not.

So what separates brands that scale profitably from brands that just... scale?

Key takeaways
1
A customer acquisition strategy decides which customers you buy, through which channels and entry products, and how much you can pay for each.
2
A small slice of customers drives most of the profit, so who you acquire matters more than how many.
3
Profile your top 20% by contribution margin or 12-month LTV: first channel, entry product, discount, days to order two.
4
Set a max CAC per profile, not one blended target. A $60 CAC can be a steal and a $30 CAC a loss.
5
Seed lookalikes with the top 20%, exclude discount-only buyers, and report on the 20% every month.
In this post
01How top teams think about acquisition →
02From insight to execution →
03What a value-based acquisition strategy is →
04Top 20% customer profile chart →
05How to build it in 5 steps →
06Customer acquisition strategy FAQ →
Part 1 · The story

They Think About Acquisition Differently

I have noticed that the teams of top CEOs & CMOs whose companies are scaling profitably put a different lens on acquisition. Here is how they think differently:

1] They know a customer base follows a power law. A small minority of customers generating a disproportionate share of value. That powerful yet small group buys more often, churns less, and rarely needs a discount to convert. These aren't just "better customers" they're a different species entirely. The long tail, meanwhile, costs almost as much to acquire but never shows up again. Treating both groups the same isn't just inefficient. It's mathematically expensive.

2] Acquisition is the best touch to create another top 20% customer. For example, $60 CAC for someone who behaves like your best customers is a steal. A $30 CAC for someone who sits in the long tail, never reorders, or only responds to 40% discount emails? That turns out to be a slow-moving disaster disguised in attractive CAC.

3] They treat best customers as a data set, not a vibe. They can describe top customers quantitatively: which channel is their first touch, what products they start with, how fast they get to order two, their return rate, and discount sensitivity. They have this profile down. If you can't pull this profile in five minutes, creating more of the customer you need is very challenging.

4] They see most retention "problems" as acquisition problems. They know retention starts with acquisition and no amount of clever Klaviyo flows will fix the core issue of bad customers. They acquire with a mindset that retention rates skew more "nature" than "nurture”.

They know difference between scaling and scaling profitably usually comes down to this: who you're acquiring, not how many.

From Insight To Execution

Taking insight back into how you operate is the hardest part. So, here's is where I would begin this quarter to start making impactful changes:

Build a "Top 20%" segment that everyone can see. By contribution margin or 12-month LTV, not just revenue. Tag them as a distinct segment. Make sure marketing and finance know who sits in that bucket.

Reverse-engineer their acquisition paths. Which channels first touched them? Which products did they start with? What discount profile did they see? How fast did they hit order two? Put this in a simple table

Rebuild your audiences around them. Sync your top segments as primary seeds for lookalikes. Build explicit exclusions for low-value profiles. Start training marketing platforms.

Start reporting on the 20%. Add a section to your monthly deck. Report on revenue and profit from this segment, new entries, CAC, payback for the group. Shift the conversation from "more customers" to "more of the right customers."

At the end of the day, the difference isn't better creative, it's knowing exactly who you're trying to acquire so you can replicate it.

-Alex

Part 2 · The guide

What is a customer acquisition strategy?

Definition
A customer acquisition strategy is the plan for which customers you buy, through which channels and entry products, and how much you can pay for each one.
A value-based strategy starts from your top 20% by contribution margin or 12-month LTV and sets CAC limits by the customer profile a channel brings in, not by a blended average.

Top 20% customer profile chart

Pull the same six signals for your top 20% and your long tail. The gap tells you where to point budget and how much each customer is worth paying for.

Top 20% vs long tail · worked example
The top 20% can carry a 10x higher CAC.
Six signals to pull for both groups. Illustrative numbers for one brand.
SignalTop 20%Long tail
Entry productFull-price hero SKUDiscounted bundle
First-order discountNone30–40% code
Days to 2nd order35No 2nd order
Return rate8%22%
12-month CM1 LTV$240$25
Max CAC at 3:1$80$8
At these numbers a $60 CAC on a top-20% customer earns 4:1. A $30 CAC on the long tail never pays back.
The takeaway
Set CAC limits by customer profile, not by blended average. A higher CAC is fine when it buys the top-20% profile; your entry product decides a lot of who that is.
Part 3 · Do it yourself

How to build a customer acquisition strategy around your best customers

Five steps turn the profile into budget decisions. Most of it runs on data you already have in Shopify.

Shopify + ad platforms · 5 steps
1
Rank customers by margin
Export 12-month customer sales and rank by contribution margin, not revenue.
2
Tag the top 20%
Create a Shopify customer segment so marketing and finance see the same list.
3
Profile the first order
Compare first channel, entry product, discount and days to order two against the tail.
4
Seed lookalikes, exclude the tail
Upload the top 20% as a lookalike seed; exclude discount-only buyers.
5
Report on the 20% monthly
Track new top-20% customers, their CAC and payback in your monthly deck.

Common customer acquisition mistakes

MistakeDo this instead
Optimizing one blended CACSet a max CAC per customer profile
Ranking customers by revenueRank by contribution margin or 12-month LTV
Seeding lookalikes with all buyersSeed with the top 20%, exclude discount-only buyers
Fixing bad customers with flowsFix who you acquire: retention starts at acquisition

Customer acquisition strategy FAQ

What is a customer acquisition strategy in ecommerce?
It is the plan for which customers you acquire, through which channels and entry products, and at what cost. The strongest strategies start from the customers who already create most of the profit, then point budget at channels and products that bring in more people like them.
How do I identify my most valuable customers?
Rank customers by contribution margin or 12-month LTV, not revenue, and take the top 20%. Then describe them: first channel, entry product, discount use, days to the second order and return rate. Who are your VIPs, actually? shows how to set the line with RFM scores.
How much can I pay to acquire a high-value customer?
Work back from their LTV. If a top-20% customer is worth $240 in 12-month contribution margin and you want 3:1, you can pay up to $80. A cheap CAC on a customer who never reorders is the expensive one. The LTV side is in the LTV Playbook.
Should I use my best customers as a lookalike seed?
Yes. Sync your top segment as the primary seed and build explicit exclusions for low-value profiles, so platforms learn from the customers you want more of. Broad targeting without that signal tends to buy the long tail; see the broad targeting myth.
How much revenue comes from the top 20% of customers?
Often around 70%, though it varies by brand and category. Measure your own split before you set budgets; customer concentration explains how and what a risky level looks like.

Want a sanity check on your own top 20%? Who they are, how to define them, and how to find more of them. Reply "TOP20" and I'll tell you where I'd start in your data.