Habit Products: The Silent Revenue Engines of E-commerce – how to find the consumable products customers rebuy

Unlock the secret to sustainable eCommerce growth by identifying 'habit products' that drive repeat purchases and long-term customer value, transforming your ad strategy.

Alex JostAlex Jost
Founder of RetentionX · Dec 25, 2025 · 8-minute read
Key takeaways
1
A habit product is an entry product that ends up in a customer’s routine: it runs out, gets rebought and pulls other SKUs along.
2
Fake heroes win on CTR, CAC and ROAS but bring in customers who buy once.
3
Judge each entry product by second-order rate, same-product rebuy, days to reorder and 12-month units, not by front-end metrics.
4
In 3 Shopify brands, the 2nd-order rate of the top 10 entry products ranged from 1.6% to 41.4% in apparel and 26.7% to 43.9% in personal care.
5
Sticky SKUs earn a higher CAC ceiling: lead acquisition with them and keep fake heroes as upsells.
In this post
01What habit products are→
02Habit product vs fake hero scorecard→
03How to calculate stickiness→
04Why they deserve more ad spend→
05How to find them in Shopify→
06FAQ→

Some products look incredible on paper. Strong click-through. Healthy CAC. Great creative performance. But here's what the dashboard doesn't show: those same SKUs might be chipping away at your unit economics.

We see this constantly. A product wins attention—seasonal kit, limited drop, discount bundle—but the customers it brings in buy once and disappear.

Meanwhile, a “boring” serum or a basic cleanser sits lower in the media mix, even though buyers of that product come back every 6 weeks and layer in more SKUs over time.

One product looks like a hero. The other actually behaves like one.

What are habit products?

Here is the short definition, then the distinction that matters for your ad spend.

Definition
A habit product is a product, often a consumable, that customers use up and rebuy on a rhythm, so the customers it brings in come back on their own.
Consumable products like skincare, razor blades, coffee or supplements are the classic case, but a core basic in apparel can play the same role. The opposite is a fake hero: a gift set, drop or seasonal item that wins the first order and rarely the second. Related: what a hero product really is.

The Distinction That Matters

Habit products are SKUs that end up in your customers' daily or weekly routine. They run out. They get replenished. They create a natural rhythm of repeat purchases and they pull other products along with them.

Fake heroes are SKUs that perform well in acquisition metrics but produce customers who don't return frequently (or ever). They're often gift-able items, seasonal, or novelty-driven. Fake heroes have a way of feeling like wins in the moment and start feeling like losses 12 months later.

This creates issues because most brands allocate media spend based on front-end performance—CTR, CAC, ROAS—without weighting for what happens after order one.

Habit-forming products get overlooked, and retention teams are left trying to engage customers who were never going to stick in the first place.

Breaking that cycle is how durable growth actually happens.

Habit product vs fake hero: the entry product scorecard

Use this chart to sort your top entry products. Each signal compares the customers one product brought in against your store average.

Entry product scorecard
A habit product wins after order one. A fake hero wins before it.
Compare the first buyers of each entry product with your store average over 12 months.
SignalHabit productFake hero
2nd-order rateAbove store averageBelow store average
Same-product rebuyMeaningful: it runs outClose to zero
Days to 2nd orderNear the product’s use-up timeLong, or never
Units per customer, 12 moKeeps risingFlat after order 1
Basket spreadPulls in other SKUsStays single-SKU
Return rateAt or below averageOften above (gifts, sizing)
Where it looks goodRetention and LTVCTR, CAC, ROAS
Directional chart: use your own store average as the line between the two columns.

A product that fails three or more signals is a fake hero, however good its ROAS looks.

What the data shows across 3 Shopify brands

We pulled the top 10 entry products of three Shopify brands to see how far apart they really are.

RetentionX data · 3 Shopify brands
The entry product decides who comes back.
Top 10 entry products by new customers per brand, all-time data to 17 Nov 2026.
Brand2nd-order rate, low → highSame-product rebuy, low → highWhat the spread shows
Apparel1.6% → 41.4%0% → 4.3%Core jeans 38–41% vs seasonal puffers 6–13%
Flowers & gifts25.7% → 37.0%6.4% → 12.8%Narrow: every top product brings back 1 in 4 to 1 in 3
Personal care26.7% → 43.9%1.9% → 32.9%Cleanser 43.9% / 32.9% vs gift shave set 28.9% / 1.9%
2nd-order rate = share of customers whose first order contained the product who ordered again. Same-product rebuy = share who bought that product again. Apparel excludes one legacy 2020–21 SKU (83.8%); personal care excludes 2 order add-ons. Newer products have had less time to repeat. Anonymized RetentionX stores, ratios only.
In consumables the habit shows up as rebuys of the same product. In apparel it shows up as second orders from core basics.

How to calculate stickiness per entry product

Four numbers per entry product, measured for the customers whose first order contained it, tell you if it behaves like a habit. The first one is your repeat purchase rate, cut by first product.

The four stickiness formulas
2nd-order rate per entry product
first buyers of X who ordered again ÷ all first buyers of X
Same-product rebuy rate
first buyers of X who bought X again ÷ first buyers of X
Days to reorder
median days from first to second order, first buyers of X
12-month units per customer
units bought by first buyers of X in 12 months ÷ first buyers of X

Worked example: 1,000 customers start with a cleanser and 380 order again within 12 months: a 38% second-order rate. Another 1,000 start with a gift set and 150 order again: 15%. At the same €30 CAC, both cost €30,000, but that buys 380 repeat customers in one case and 150 in the other: about €79 vs €200 per repeat customer.

Why habit products deserve more of your ad budget

Once you can see stickiness per SKU, three shifts follow. The same logic applies to price: your entry price sets your retention ceiling.

Three Shifts Worth Making

  1. Not all revenue is equal; recurring units are worth more. A product that gets repurchased 5–10 times over 12–18 months is fundamentally different from a one-off im"Stickiness" is a metric, not a feeling. You can actually measure stickiness. Repeat purchase rate by first-product SKU, average units per customer over 12 months, time between repurchases. Look at these metrics across your SKUs and the data will show you which products actually behave like habits—and which ones just look good in ads.

  2. Your CAC ceiling should be higher for sticky SKUs. You can rationally pay more to acquire a customer into a product that repeats frequently with healthy margins. When you lead with non-sticky SKUs, you're trapped in a tight CAC box with no future contribution margin to bail you out. By knowing the SKUs you can optimize acquisition and CAC.

  3. Acquisition and retention aren't separate problems. If the marketing team is pushing customers into fake heroes, lifecycle teams are forced to do very hard work later. If acquisition leads with habit products, retention becomes guiding a journey the customer already wants to take.

How to find your habit products in Shopify

This takes one export and an afternoon. You can also read these numbers per product in RetentionX.

In Shopify · 5 steps
1
Export first orders
Shopify orders export, filtered to each customer’s first order (last 12 months).
2
Group by first product
Keep products that started enough customers for the rates to be stable.
3
Calculate the four signals
2nd-order rate, same-product rebuy, days to reorder, 12-month units.
4
Add margin and returns
Contribution margin and return rate for the same customers.
5
Rank and rebalance
Habit products lead ads and landing pages; fake heroes become upsells.

For the products that pass, time your reminders to their use-up cycle with replenishment timing.

Where I'd Start

Priority 1:
Identify your true habit products with data. Pull a 12-month view and calculate, for each product that frequently appears as a first purchase: repeat rate, average units per customer, contribution margin, return rate. Highlight the SKUs where customers come back again and again with strong margin.

Priority 2: 

Shift spend toward habit builders. Rebalance creative, landing pages, and feed logic so your stickiest products lead. Fake heroes can still exist as upsells or seasonal plays—but they shouldn't be your front door.

Priority 3:
Update your reporting to include stickiness. Add one line to your monthly review: share of acquisition spend going to habit products vs. everything else. When leadership sees that number, the conversation changes.

Common mistakes when picking entry products

MistakeDo this instead
Ranking entry products by ROASRank by 2nd-order rate and 12-month value of the customers they bring
Calling every bestseller a heroCheck if bestseller buyers come back; treat it like a loss leader only if it pays back
Judging new products too earlyGive each entry product at least one full use-up cycle first
Counting only same-product rebuysIn apparel or durables, count any 2nd order: the habit can be the category
One CAC target for every SKUSet a higher CAC ceiling for sticky entry products

If you do this well, your revenue stops being a series of spikes and starts to feel like layers: each cohort adds recurring, high-margin revenue on top of the last.

Acquisition isn't about fighting retention—it's about feeding it. In other words: your media plan should look like a map of your customers' routines, and less like a merch team's seasonal mood board. 

Want to dive in further? Read my article on product stickiness

If you want a sanity check on which of your products are true habit builders—and how much of your spend is actually backing them—reply "STICKY" and I'll tell you what I'd look at in your data first.

FAQ: habit products and consumable products

What are consumable products?
Consumable products are goods that get used up and need replacing, like skincare, razor blades, coffee, cleaning supplies or supplements. In ecommerce they matter because customers run out on a predictable rhythm, which makes them natural repeat-purchase products. Not every consumable builds a habit, though: check its second-order rate and same-product rebuy rate before you treat it as one.
What is a habit product?
A habit product is an entry product that ends up in a customer’s daily or weekly routine. It runs out, gets replenished and often pulls other products along. You can spot one in your data: its first buyers order again more often and sooner than your store average, and many of them buy the same product again.
What is a fake hero product?
A fake hero is a product that looks great in acquisition metrics such as CTR, CAC or ROAS but brings in customers who rarely buy again. Gift sets, seasonal items, limited drops and discount bundles are common examples. Keep them, but as upsells or seasonal plays rather than the front door of your ad spend.
How do you find your best entry product?
Pull every customer’s first order for the last 12 months and group customers by the products in it. For each product with enough first buyers, calculate the second-order rate, same-product rebuy rate, days to reorder, 12-month units, margin and return rate. The product that scores best across these, not the one with the best ROAS, is your best entry product.
Should you pay a higher CAC for habit products?
Yes, within limits. A customer who comes back every six weeks earns back a higher acquisition cost than one who buys once. Set the CAC ceiling per entry product from its 12-month contribution margin, not from first-order margin. Products that don’t repeat should stay inside a tight CAC box.